Who Got It Right and Who Got It Wrong? Critics and Composers
by Maureen Buja We were looking at a book of musical quotations the other day and found some things that make one so glad to have a sense of perspective. Here, John Gregory, writing in 1766 in his A Comparative View of the State and Faculties of Man with Those of the Animal World , had this to say about what composer? ‘[The style of COMPOSER] sometimes pleases by its spirit and a wild luxuriancy … but possesses too little of the elegance and pathetic expression of music to remain long in the public taste.’ Hmmm. So we want a mid-18th century composer who had spirit and a sense of luxury but lacked elegance…. Mozart? Hummel? No, they’re too late. Gregory was referring to the style of the music of Haydn, who, of all composers of his era, has remained in the public taste where so many of his contemporaries have vanished. Hardy: Joseph Haydn, 1791 We have two composers with two very different views of conductors. The first, a composer, suffered poor performances ...