Showing posts with label Schumann. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Schumann. Show all posts

Friday, November 6, 2026

The Best Symphony of Each Decade of the 1800s

  

The form entered the century as a genteel curtain-raiser: twenty minutes of Classical politeness, often featuring courtly, aristocratic minuets.

It left the century capable of embodying autobiography, nationalist argument, spiritual crisis, and philosophical statement – sometimes all at once, and sometimes for the better part of two hours.

This list traces that transformation decade by decade, picking the symphony that did the most to move the genre forward.

1800s – Beethoven, Symphony No. 3, “Eroica” (1803–1804)   

Beethoven’s third symphony broke the rules the genre had followed for decades. Before 1804, symphonies were expected to last between twenty and thirty minutes. However, Beethoven’s Third lasts nearly fifty minutes. Its opening movement alone is longer than many of Haydn’s and Mozart’s symphonies.

Christian Hornemann: Ludwig von Beethoven, 1803

Christian Hornemann: Ludwig von Beethoven, 1803

That massive first movement isn’t the only stand-out moment in the work. The second movement is a dramatic funeral march; the third a beefy scherzo with three horns; and the finale is a massive set of variations on a theme.

That doesn’t even touch on the extramusical story of the work. It was originally meant to be a tribute to Napoleon. Still, after Napoleon declared himself emperor in 1804, Beethoven was furious and struck out the symphony’s nickname so violently that he tore a hole in the title page.

It was a fittingly dramatic coda to the creation of a work that went on to shape the rest of the 19th century.

1810s – Beethoven, Symphony No. 7 (1811–1812)   

Beethoven’s Third permitted symphonists to dream bigger, but his Seventh let them find inspiration in one of music’s smallest, most basic elements: rhythm.

Each movement of Beethoven’s Seventh showcases a different, insistent pulse. The first movement uses swinging, dotted rhythms; the second, hushed funereal march rhythms; the third, bouncy presto rhythms; and the fourth, swirling sforzandos on dazzling fly-by sixteenth notes.

As different as each movement is, this focus on rhythm lends coherence to the entire work.

Richard Wagner called this symphony “the apotheosis of the dance.” It gave future composers a blueprint for building large-scale orchestral works around rhythmic drive rather than melody alone.

1820s – Beethoven, Symphony No. 9 (1822–1824)    

You might be thinking, Beethoven again? But it’s undeniable: for three decades in a row, Beethoven composed what is unquestionably the most important symphony of the decade.

Beethoven’s ninth (and final) symphony is where he pushed himself furthest creatively. First, it outpaced even the Third Symphony in length, taking around 70 minutes to perform.

More consequentially, he created a final movement scored for orchestra and voices, setting a text from Schiller’s Ode to Joy in an ecstatic celebration of universal brotherhood.

Beethoven’s Ninth has reverberated ever since. Mahler answered Beethoven directly, writing choral symphonies of his own. Brahms avoided choral writing in his symphonies entirely, aiming to prove a purely orchestral symphony alone could pack the same punch. Meanwhile, Wagner found the Ninth so overwhelming he came to believe it marked the culmination – and the end – of purely instrumental music and turned to opera instead.

This symphony isn’t just influential for how it sounds; it’s influential for the ideas it unleashed.

1830s – Berlioz, Symphonie Fantastique (1830)       

Berlioz heard Beethoven’s Ninth in 1828 and was deeply inspired. Two years later, he took the form a step further, giving his own symphony an overt narrative.

Inspired by his obsession with Shakespearean actress Harriet Smithson, the Fantastique tells the (suspiciously autobiographical) story of a drug-fueled artist obsessing over a woman. The story ends with the artist’s execution and a witches’ sabbath.

The young Hector Berlioz

The young Hector Berlioz

In the symphony, Berlioz uses a device called an idée fixe, a single melody that recurs and mutates across all five movements. It grants the symphony a new kind of unity: narrative rather than purely structural or rhythmic.

The orchestration was also groundbreaking, calling for col legno bowing (string playing that uses the wooden part of the bow), offstage oboe, and church bells.

The flash and colour of Berlioz’s storytelling and orchestration inspired composers for the rest of the century, from Liszt’s symphonic poems to the psychological programs of Tchaikovsky’s later symphonies.

1840s – Mendelssohn, Symphony No. 3, “Scottish” (1829–1842)   

After Berlioz’s fever dream of a symphony, Mendelssohn wrote one that also embraced the idea of thematic material transforming from movement to movement.

However, where Berlioz aimed for narrative, flash, and spectacle, Mendelssohn focused on atmosphere and control, proving the two impulses could coexist within Romanticism rather than compete. Even the symphony’s structural innovation – having each movement performed without any break in between – is inextricably linked to the fact that the work employs the traditional four-movement structure.

Eduard Magnus: Felix Mendelssohn, 1846 (Berlin State Library)

Eduard Magnus: Felix Mendelssohn, 1846 (Berlin State Library)

In the end, Mendelssohn’s third became a model for composers who wanted emotional impact without completely abandoning convention.

The “Scottish” took Mendelssohn thirteen years to finish. He began it after visiting a ruined chapel at Holyrood, Scotland, during his European Grand Tour in 1829.

“In the deep twilight we went today to the palace where Queen Mary lived and loved… The chapel below is now roofless… Everything is ruined, decayed, and the clear heavens pour in. I think I have found there the beginning of my ‘Scottish’ Symphony.”

Although he may have found the beginning there, he didn’t finish it until 1842.

1850s – Schumann, Symphony No. 3, “Rhenish” (1850)   

Robert Schumann wrote this symphony in a five-week burst in the fall of 1850, between November 2 and December 9. Although it was the last symphony he completed, it’s numbered as his third.

Schumann gravitated naturally toward songwriting throughout his career, and that instinct shaped his symphonic writing too. He admired how Mendelssohn had folded songlike, lyrical melodies into orchestral form, and he used that device in his own symphonies.

Robert Schumann

Robert Schumann

That same instinct extended to a taste for storytelling, though Schumann resisted attaching an explicit program the way Berlioz had. Instead, the “Rhenish” suggests its story rather than narrating it: the second movement evokes the Rhine River, and the fourth movement portrays a “solemn ceremony,” inspired by an archbishop’s elevation to cardinal at Cologne Cathedral, which Schumann had witnessed in person.

Where Beethoven had expanded the symphony in his third and ninth symphonies by making its four movements longer, Schumann expanded it by adding a fifth movement outright – treating movement count itself as a variable, rather than a fixed convention, to be adjusted to fit the material.

That precedent gave later composers room to do the same: Mahler, working within an even more flexible sense of symphonic structure, would take that same license further.

1860s – Tchaikovsky, Symphony No. 1, “Winter Dreams” (1866–1868)   

The 1860s were a quiet stretch, symphonically speaking. Brahms was a decade into writing his first symphony but paralysed by Beethoven’s enormous shadow. Meanwhile, Bruckner, Borodin, and Dvořák were still young men finding their voices.

A 26-year-old Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky stepped into that gap. Tchaikovsky, a recent graduate of the St. Petersburg Conservatory, wrote his first symphony while suffering something close to a breakdown from insomnia and overwork.

Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky at 23

Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky at 23

He revised it twice over the following years, never fully satisfied.

What survives is the first symphony by a Russian composer to enter the standard modern repertoire. Although Tchaikovsky’s later symphonies ultimately overshadowed it, this first one is important, proving that the German-Austrian tradition wasn’t the only path to symphonic legitimacy.

1870s – Brahms, Symphony No. 1 (1854–1876)   Play

Brahms began sketching this symphony in the 1850s and didn’t finish it for over twenty years, paralysed by the idea that any symphony he wrote would be compared to Beethoven’s.

He was right to be nervous about the inevitable comparisons, because they came. In fact, when it finally did premiere, in 1876, a conductor dubbed it “Beethoven’s Tenth” – fortunately for Brahms, meant as a compliment.

The symphony’s Beethovenian C minor-to-C major trajectory, its finale’s echo of the “Ode to Joy” theme, and its sheer structural and technical rigour all read as a direct answer to Beethoven.

Johannes Brahms, 1866

Johannes Brahms, 1866

Brahms was working against another headwind too: Liszt and Wagner’s flashy new symphonic poems and music dramas were making the case that the old purely instrumental forms Brahms treasured were becoming obsolete.

Brahms’s success with this work breathed new life into a form that Liszt and Wagner had all but declared obsolete.

1880s – Dvořák, Symphony No. 7 (1885)   

Antonín Dvořák came up with the idea for the first movement of his Seventh Symphony after seeing a train of Czech men travelling to Prague to perform at the National Theatre.

Dvořák was inspired to write a serious intellectual work that would depict the drama of the national struggle for independence while being imbued with Czech character.

Antonín Dvořák, 1882

Antonín Dvořák, 1882

His most famous symphony is the Ninth Symphony, nicknamed the “New World.” But that popularity has eclipsed many of his other works, including the seventh. Musicologist Donald Tovey called his seventh “among the greatest and purest examples in this art-form since Beethoven.”

Dvořák’s seventh also contained an unspoken, extramusical argument: that Czech composers like him could use the symphony – widely seen as a primarily Austro-German art form – to express nationalist ideas and emotions.

Between the 1860s and 1880s, Tchaikovsky and Dvořák proved that nationalist identity wasn’t a limitation on the symphony. Still, a source of new vitality – a tradition Sibelius and Shostakovich would carry into the 20th century.

1890s – Mahler, Symphony No. 2 (1888–1894)  

Mahler’s second symphony doesn’t close out the century so much as it kicks the door open to the next one.

Subtitled the “Resurrection”, it runs for nearly ninety minutes, demanding a massive orchestra, offstage brass, a soprano and alto soloist, and a full chorus that doesn’t enter until the final movement, where it sings a text written in part by Mahler himself.

Emil Orlík: Gustav Mahler, 1902

Emil Orlík: Gustav Mahler, 1902

The symphony’s use of the human voice, its willingness to confront death and resurrection head-on as explicit textual subject matter, and its refusal to resolve neatly within Classical proportions all point away from the 19th century and squarely toward the next one.

That expanded sense of what a symphony could be – part autobiography, part spectacle, part spiritual reckoning – became the inheritance every 20th-century symphonist had to reckon with.

Conclusion

Line up all ten choices and a pattern appears that no single entry reveals on its own: the story of the 19th-century symphony is the story of composers answering their predecessors, one symphony at a time.

Beethoven answered Haydn and Mozart by making the form bigger and stranger. Berlioz answered Beethoven by making it explicitly personal. Brahms answered Beethoven, but it took him twenty years of honing his creative powers. Mahler wrote such long, complicated works that he seemed to answer everyone at once.

Sibelius, Shostakovich, and the rest of the 20th century’s symphonists inherited a form so thoroughly reinvented that “symphony” stopped meaning any one thing – and started meaning everything.

Saturday, May 2, 2026

Facing Alexander Scriabin (Died on April 27, 1915)

 by Hermione Lai  April 27th, 2026


Alexander Scriabin

Alexander Scriabin

Chords become alien, textures are all over the place, and the music doesn’t breathe in regular phrases. It’s almost like getting seriously lost. How can you communicate something that can’t be grasped?

No Place to Hide

The harmonic language expresses colours and metaphysical visions, not really something you can handle in the practice room. And I can’t even imagine having to memorise the music. I’ve heard it said that pianists need a kind of vulnerability to perform his music, as it is impossible to hide behind structure or tradition.

I think it’s time I confront my demon. So, to commemorate Scriabin’s death on 27 April 1915, let’s have a quick guide to his 10 piano sonatas. Mind you, I’ll try to stay away from too many technical descriptions, and I am immensely grateful to Simon Nicholls for his 1996 notes accompanying Marc-André Hamelin’s interpretations.  

Between Prayer and Despair

Scriabin’s first attempt at a piano sonata was written at the age of fourteen, while he was at the Cadet Corps in Moscow. This turned out to be his Sonata-Fantasy in G-sharp minor of 1886, a work that was never published. So let’s forget about this work and move straight to his Sonata No. 1 in F minor, Op. 6, published seven years later in 1893.

Josef Lhevinne

Josef Lhevinne

Scriabin had been trying to compete with the unbelievable virtuosity of his classmate Josef Lhevinne, and he injured his right arm and hand. Doctors told him that he would never recover. Thus, this first sonata, as Scriabin calls it, was a cry against fate and against God.

That cry is heard in the opening measures of the movement, which at times almost sounds like Brahms. Doubts and prayers appear in the second movement in a musical language influenced by César Franck.

The Rondo movement sounds like the finale, but that place is taken by a seriously gloomy Funeral March. It all sounds like Scriabin is trying to find his bearings in a late-Romantic language, throwing in snippets of Chopin, Schumann, and Modest Mussorgsky.   

Nature Transformed

Alexander Scriabin

Alexander Scriabin

It took Scriabin the better part of five years to write and publish his Sonata No. 2, Op. 19. The piece unfolds in two movements, and the composer told us what to expect in a short programme note.

“The first part evokes the calm of the night by the seashore in the South; in the development we hear the sombre agitation of the depths. The section in E Major represents the tender moonlight which comes after the first dark of night. The second movement, presto, shows the stormy agitation of the vast expanse of ocean.”

This sonata is one of Scriabin’s most famous works, and it is technically approachable. It certainly helps that in the opening movement, the exposition, development, and recapitulation all start with the same music.

Scriabin’s style has changed in comparison to his first sonata, as the piano writing is much more delicate, almost in the style of Chopin. There are plenty of polyrhythms in the opening movement, while the finale features endless streams of triplets against a marching rhythm.   

A Soul’s Journey

Scriabin’s Sonata No. 3 was composed between 1897 and 1898, around the time he married the young pianist Vera Ivanovna Isaakovich. Initially, he is said to have called the finished work “Gothic,” like the impression of a ruined castle.

Several years later, he or his second wife, Tatyana Schloezer, came up with a different description and nickname, namely “States of Being.” And in this description, all four movements represent a story of a soul’s strife, from being free and untamed to reaching the abyss of nothingness.

A clever person once said that composers who issue programmes for their music often live to regret it, and that seems pretty apt in this case. The music, however, has once again advanced in style. All movements are closely linked to each other in a cyclic treatment reminiscent of Liszt.

Hints of Wagner’s Tristan float through parts of the closing movement, which really does not have a happy ending. There is plenty of counterpoint and a seemingly symphonic conception underneath it all.  

From Desire to Radiance

As Scriabin went through a turbulent personal period, his musical language was transforming as well. His Sonata No. 4, issued as Op. 30 in 1903, is headed by a poem describing a flight to a distant star.

Thinly veiled in transparent cloud
A star shines softly, far and lonely.
How beautiful! The azure secret
Of its radiance beckons, lulls me…
Vehement desire, sensual, insane, sweet…
Now! Joyfully I fly upward toward you,
Freely I take wing.
Mad dance, godlike play…
I draw near in my longing…
Drink you in, sea of light, you light of my own self…

In this shortest of his sonatas, Scriabin uses cyclic themes throughout the 2-movement work. We find unusual harmonies and plenty of “Tristan” references in the opening introduction.

The second movement, which follows without a break, features plenty of new sounds. The first-movement theme returns in a jubilant manner and in an explosion of overwhelming joy. Compared to the sombre finales of the first three sonatas, this one is full of light and ecstasy.   

Ecstasy Unleashed

Scriabin’s Sonata No. 5 was written shortly after his orchestral “Poem of Ecstasy” in 1907. Apparently, he wrote this sonata in only a couple of days as his musical style had evolved once more.

The “Poem of Ecstasy” features a lengthy poetic introduction, describing in rather sexual terms the release from the unconscious mind.

I call you to life, mysterious forces!
Drowned in the obscure depths
of the creative spirit, timid
Embryos of life, to you I bring audacity!

I am not sure we could call it a transitional work, but the music relates directly and clearly to the tonal system, yet many features already point to his late style. We are certainly treated to a contrast between ecstatic fast themes and languid slow ones.

We find cyclic links between sections, and this sonata might be the most difficult among this group. Some parts are downright unpianistic, but we do find some of Scriabin’s most creative harmonic writing, nevertheless.   Play

Fear and Shadows

After Scriabin completed “Prometheus,” he set to work on his Sonata No. 6, Op. 62.

There is no programme, and Scriabin never played it in public. He considered it frightening, dark, mysterious, and dangerous.

The music is disturbing, switching between playful and fleeting, and within this concentrated mysteriousness, tonality has almost disappeared. One might practically call this sonata atonal.

In addition, a transformation of the piano sound had taken place. We find monolithic chords, fluttering airborne impulses, and what has been called an arching theme of boundless sensuality.

There is plenty of febrile hyperactivity that exceeds the range of the keyboard, and it gives the impression of a dream. This sonata remains obscure, and you won’t see it much on concert programmes.   

White Mass

Scriabin at the piano

Scriabin at the piano

With the 7th Sonata of 1911, actually finished before the No. 6, we are squarely in the grasp of the composer’s Messianic pretensions. Subtitled “White Mass,” it features wondrous sonorities, extreme dissonances, and a number of themes related to heavenly exorcism.

Scriabin set out to create a prophetic atmosphere; just listen to the opening fanfares and the lightning flickering across the score. Chiming bells present a motif of invocation, and arpeggios drift like clouds of incense.

It all, predictably, ends in a mighty climax, a light flutter of trills and a polyrhythmic ascension after a chord that spans 5 octaves. Many consider this sonata Scriabin’s crowning achievement.

Scriabin loved to play this sonata in public, but the reactions were rather cold. There are just too many technical difficulties, and the harmonic structure and rhythm tend to be a great challenge to pianists.   

Quietest Storm

The Sonata No. 8 turns out to be the quietest of the set. Actually, it was the last sonata to be finished in 1913, and Scriabin spoke enthusiastically of it. But it is the longest and most complex of all Scriabin’s works.

Apparently, Scriabin thought of its form as a quasi-geometrical organisation that bridges the visible natural world with the invisible artistic realm. He also thought himself superior to Bach in terms of contrapuntal writing.

We do find plenty of counterpoint and less dissonance as the entire sonata exudes a static mood. This is possibly what Scriabin had in mind when he called parts “at perfect peace.”

Horribly difficult to perform, on par with the 5th and 7th Sonatas, but it has a much more mature personality. The material for this sonata is summed up in a final dance, and then everything just dissolves.   

Black Mass

In terms of popularity, the Sonata No. 9, subtitled “Black Mass”, is by far the most frequently performed of the set. That subtitle actually comes from an admirer, who described the atmosphere as Satanic.

The work dates from 1912, and it is one of the more approachable sonatas, both in terms of technical demand and in understanding the composer’s mystic ideals. Opening dissonances and repeated notes reach a nightmarish first climax.

The lyrical second subject appears in various seductive guises and turns into a grotesque march. The music becomes more intoxicating by the minute, and the coda evokes the cackle of the devil. Yet, it all ends in subdued quietness, or as A.E. Hull calls it “molecular vertigo.”

Into the Light

In his final sonata, Scriabin returns to the harmony of nature. Sonata No. 10 is bright and sunny, and much less dissonant. It was written on his country estate. The serene opening finishes with luminous trills in a blazing vision of light.

There are plenty of fluttering chords and joyous screams, and Scriabin thought he was on the brink of great new developments. Surprisingly, this sonata is more tonal and features more exposed tonal chords.

Scriabin died in 1915, but he was convinced that “the masses need to be shaken up, in order to purify the human organisation.” I wonder what he might have thought of World War I and the Russian Revolution.

After looking at and listening to the 10 sonatas by Scriabin, my fear of his music will probably never completely go away. It’s like stepping into quicksand, with no anchors for fingers or the mind. And maybe that’s the point; you’ll just have to let go and lunge into the music headfirst.

Friday, February 6, 2026

The Most Passionate Composer Love Letters of All Time, Part 1

  

Today, we’re looking at love letters from ten composers, including Mozart being very saucy on a business trip, Brahms pining over Clara Schumann, and Haydn making a shocking confession to his mistress.

Joseph Haydn, 1791

Joseph Haydn

Joseph Haydn

In these two love letters to his mistress, singer Luigia Polzelli, Haydn writes about her husband’s fatal illness…and longs for “four eyes [to] be closed”, a reference to his hope that his own wife will die, too!

London, 14th March 1791

Most esteemed Polzelli,

I am very sorry for you in your present circumstances, and I hope that your poor husband will die at any moment; you did well to put him in the hospital, to keep him alive…

London, 4th August 1791

Dear Polzelli!

…As far as your husband is concerned, I tell you that Providence has done well to liberate you from this heavy yoke, and for him, too, it is better to be in another world than to remain useless in this one. The poor man has suffered enough. Dear Polzelli, perhaps, perhaps the time will come, when we both so often dreamt of, when four eyes shall be closed. Two are closed, but the other two – enough of all this, it shall be as God wills.

Learn more about why Haydn hated his wife so much.

Ludwig van Beethoven, 1812

Beethoven’s Seventh Symphony, finished in 1812   

In 1812, Beethoven wrote an impassioned love letter to an unknown woman. This letter has come to be known as the letter to the Immortal Beloved.

Beethoven in 1803

Beethoven in 1803

Though still in bed, my thoughts go out to you, my Immortal Beloved, now and then joyfully, then sadly, waiting to learn whether or not fate will hear us – I can live only wholly with you or not at all – Yes, I am resolved to wander so long away from you until I can fly to your arms and say that I am really at home with you, and can send my soul enwrapped in you into the land of spirits – Yes, unhappily it must be so – You will be the more contained since you know my fidelity to you. No one else can ever possess my heart – never – never – Oh God, why must one be parted from one whom one so loves. And yet my life in V is now a wretched life – Your love makes me at once the happiest and the unhappiest of men – At my age I need a steady, quiet life – can that be so in our connection? My angel, I have just been told that the mail coach goes every day – therefore I must close at once so that you may receive the letter at once – Be calm, only by a calm consideration of our existence can we achieve our purpose to live together – Be calm – love me – today – yesterday – what tearful longings for you – you – you – my life – my all – farewell. Oh continue to love me – never misjudge the most faithful heart of your beloved. ever thine, ever mine, ever ours…

Read more about Who was the Immortal Beloved?

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, 1783

Mozart’s Die Entführung aus dem Serail overture   

Here’s a suggestive love letter from Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart to his wife Constanze, written in 1783 when he was about to return home to Vienna after overseeing a production of his opera Die Entführung aus dem Serail in Prague.

On June 1st I’ll sleep in Prague, and on the 4th – the 4th? – I’ll be sleeping with my dear little wife; – Spruce up your sweet little nest because my little rascal here really deserves it, he has been very well behaved, but now he’s itching to possess your sweet [word erased by some unknown hand]. Just imagine that little sneak, while I am writing, he has secretly crept up on the table and now looks at me questioningly; but I, without much ado, give him a little slap – but now he is even more [word erased by some unknown hand]; well, he is almost out of control, the scoundrel.

Find out what life was like with the Mozarts in the 1780s.

Hector Berlioz, 1832

Berlioz’s Symphonie Fantastique   

Berlioz wrote this letter to actress Harriet Smithson, a woman whom he had been obsessed over and stalking for years, for whom he had composed the Symphonie fantastique and Lélio. He was begging her to return his letter:

Harriet Smithson in Romeo and Juliet

Harriet Smithson in Romeo and Juliet

If you do not desire my death, in the name of pity (I dare not say of love) let me know when I can see you. I cry mercy, pardon on my knees, between my sobs!!! Oh, wretch that I am, I did not think I deserved all that I suffer, but I bless the blows that come from your hand, await your reply like the sentence of my judge.

Learn more about the insane love story between Hector and Harriet.

Franz Liszt, 1834

Liszt’s Liebestraum No. 3  

In 1834, Franz Liszt wrote this to his new mistress, Countess Marie d’Agoult:

Marie d'Agoult in 1861

Marie d’Agoult in 1861

My heart overflows with emotion and joy! I do not know what heavenly languor, what infinite pleasure, permeates it and burns me up. It is as if I had never loved!!! Tell me whence these uncanny disturbances spring, these inexpressible foretastes of delight, these divine tremors of love. Oh! All this can only spring from you, sister, angel, woman, Marie! All this can only be, is surely nothing less than a gentle ray streaming from your fiery soul, or else some secret poignant teardrop which you have long since left in my breast.

Learn more about the passionate nature of Liszt and Marie d’Agoult’s early relationship.

Robert Schumann, 1837

Robert Schumann

Robert Schumann

In December 1837, composer Robert Schumann was in love with virtuoso pianist Clara Wieck. They’d gotten engaged a few months earlier and were doing their best to navigate their relationship, given that Clara’s father didn’t approve of their romance.

New Year’s Eve, 1837, after 11 p.m.

I have been sitting here for a whole hour. Indeed, I meant to spend the whole evening writing to you, but no words would come. Sit down beside me now, slip your arm round me, and let us gaze peacefully, blissfully, into each other’s eyes…

How happy we are, Clara! Let us kneel together, Clara, my Clara, so close that I can touch you, in this solemn hour.

On the morning of the 1st, 1838.

What a heavenly morning! All the bells are ringing; the sky is so golden and blue and clear – and before me lies your letter. I send you my first kiss, beloved.

Learn more about the brutal court case between Robert, Clara, and her father.

Johannes Brahms, 1858

Brahms’s Piano Concerto No. 1, Movement 2 (he once told Clara this was a portrait of her)    

Brahms had complicated feelings for his mentor and dear friend Clara Wieck Schumann.

In 1858, her husband Robert had died two years earlier, and Clara was on tour in the Netherlands to make money to support her family. Brahms came to her home in Düsseldorf, in part to help watch her children. He wrote to her during her tour:

My beloved friend,

Night has come on again, and it is already late, but I can do nothing but think of you and am constantly looking at your dear letter and portrait. What have you done to me? Can’t you remove the spell you have cast over me? …

How are you? I did not want to ask you to write, but do so long for letters from you. Besides, I know only too well how you are – you are holding your head up. So just write me a word or two occasionally, and I shall be happy – just a friendly greeting to say that you are keeping well and that you will be back in 14, 13, 12, 11, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 days!…

Do cheer me with writing me a few lines. I want them so badly, but above all, I want you.

Brahms and the Schumanns

Brahms and the Schumanns

Learn more about the friendship and love triangle between Robert, Clara, and Johannes.

Richard Wagner, 1863

Richard Wagner and Cosima Liszt von Bülow

Richard Wagner and Cosima Wagner

Richard Wagner and Cosima Wagner’s marriage became one of the most influential in music history. However, the relationship had an inauspicious start. Richard wrote this letter to his mistress Maria Volkl shortly after first declaring his love to Cosima (!):

Now, my darling, prepare the house for my return, so that I can relax there in comfort, as I very much long to do… And plenty of perfume: buy the best bottles, so that it smells really sweet. Heavens! How I’m looking forward to relaxing with you again at last. (I hope the pink drawers are ready, too???) – Yes, indeed! Just be nice and gentle, I deserve to be well looked after for a change.

Gustav Mahler

During their engagement, Gustav Mahler wrote this letter to his fiancée Alma, to let her know she must decide between becoming his wife or pursuing her passion for composing music.

Almschi, I beg you, read this letter carefully. Our relationship must not degenerate into a mere flirt. Before we speak again, we must have clarified everything, you must know what I demand and expect of you, and what I can give in return – what you must be for me. You must “renounce” (your word) everything superficial and conventional, all vanity and outward show (concerning your individuality and your work) – you must surrender yourself to me unconditionally… in return you must wish for nothing except my love! And what that is, Alma, I cannot tell you – I have already spoken too much about it. But let me tell you just this: for someone I love the way I would love you if you were to become my wife, I can forfeit all my life and all my happiness.

Learn more about the beautiful Alma Schindler’s background, her marriage to Gustav, and why he wrote this letter.

Jean Sibelius, 1891   

Sibelius wrote this letter to his fiancée Aino in early January 1891:

My own Aino darling,

Thank you for your letter and your Christmas cards. Your relatives have all been very kind to me. Please give them my respects and thank them most warmly, won’t you. But it is you who loves me more than anyone else has done, and I want you to be sure that I love you and belong to you with all my heart. Every time you write to me, I discover some new aspect of your personality. It makes me feel as if you are a store of treasures to which only I have the key, and you can imagine how proud I am to own it. You are so natural and sincere, which I like. When in the future we have a home of our own and are together alone, we must never be anything other than wholly ourselves, natural, tender towards each other, and devoted. I think and hope that you will be content with me in this respect. It is perhaps unmanly to say so, but you know, Aino, that I have always wanted to be caressed and have always missed its absence. At home, I was the only one who was demonstrative, and this in spite of the fact that I was basically very shy. But up to now, only you have caressed me, and perhaps you have thought it tiresome of me to ask you often to do this, my darling. This could well have remained unwritten, but as I am writing as quickly as I am thinking (hence my superb handwriting!), and this came into my head, it can just as well go into the letter. I sometimes cannot believe that a person like you loves me, for you are a wonderful woman.

Aino and Jean Sibelius

Aino and Jean Sibelius


Friday, April 25, 2025

10 Pieces of Classical Music About Childhood

 

Classical music sometimes has a reputation of being solely for elderly people. If that’s true (spoiler alert: it’s not), it’s certainly strange how many pieces of classical music are about childhood and youth.

Today we’re looking at classical music inspired by childhood.

music inspired by childhood

© soundgirls.org

Robert Schumann: Kinderszenen (1838) 

Robert Schumann’s Kinderszenen (“Songs from Childhood”) is a set of thirteen pieces for solo piano about childhood.

Robert was twenty-eight at the time he wrote these pieces, and he was dating the nineteen-year-old piano superstar Clara Wieck.

For a variety of reasons, Clara had always been mature for her age, and at one point she observed that Robert was “like a child.” Robert, amused, decided to embrace his childlike nature, took her idea, and ran with it.

The pieces in this collection include Blind Man’s Buff, Knight of the Hobbyhorse, and, most famously, Dreaming (better-known by its German title, Träumerei). 

Teresa Carreño: Mi Teresita (ca 1885) 

Teresa Carreño was one of the most famous women composers of her generation, and Mi Teresita (“My Little Teresa”) is one of her most famous works.

It’s a waltz that was written for her third child, Teresita, who had been born in 1882. (As a bit of trivia, Carreño had six children in all: one by French violinist Émile Sauret, three by Italian baritone Giovanni Tagliapietra, and two more by German pianist Eugen d’Albert.)

Teresita would become a concert pianist like her mother.

Amy Beach: Children’s Carnival (1894) 

In 1894, twenty-seven-year-old American composer Amy Beach wrote six charming piano pieces for young players. She called the works Children’s Carnival.

The Carnival portrayed different stock characters often found in commedia dell’arte or pantomime, such as the meddling merchant Pantalon, the street-smart and gossipy maid Columbina, and her nimble, quick-thinking love interest, Harlequin.

Beach portrays each character with sweet and satisfying innocence.

Claude Debussy: Children’s Corner (1906-08) 

In January 1905, Claude Debussy’s married mistress Emma Bardac became pregnant. That spring, both Debussy and Bardac divorced from their respective spouses.

In October 1905, their little daughter Claude-Emma, whom they nicknamed Chouchou, was born. Debussy found Chouchou to be delightful beyond words.

Debussy with his daughter Chou-Chou

Debussy with his daughter Chou-Chou

To celebrate his love for her, he wrote a six-movement suite of piano pieces called Children’s Corner. The work’s translated dedication reads, “To my dear little Chouchou, with tender apologies from her father for what follows.”

Children’s Corner portrays various scenes from childhood, including a serenade for a doll, a lullaby for an elephant, and a portrait of dancing snow.

John Alden Carpenter: Adventures in a Perambulator (1914)  

John Alden Carpenter was a composer born in Illinois in 1876. He studied music as a young man but chose not to make his living in music, instead joining the family shipping business as vice-president.

In 1914, he composed an orchestral portrait of his baby daughter Ginny’s day, perhaps taking inspiration from Richard Strauss, who, in 1903, had immortalized his own wife and baby in a tone poem called Symphonia Domestica.

Baby in Perambulator

Baby in Perambulator

Carpenter provided an incredibly detailed description of Ginny’s day from her perspective:

Every morning – after my second breakfast – if the wind and the sun are favorable, I go out. I should like to go alone, but my will is overborne…

Almost satiated with adventure, my Nurse firmly pushes me on, and almost before I recover my balance I am face to face with new sensation. The land comes to an end, and there at my feet is The Lake…

We pass on. Probably there is nothing more in the World. If there is, it is superfluous. There IS. It is Dogs!

Read more about Adventures in a Perambulator.

Florence Price: “To My Little Son” (ca 1915) 

Sometime around 1915, composer Florence Price set a melancholy poem by Julia Johnson Davis to music.

In your face I sometimes see
shadowings of the man to be
And eager dream of what my son shall be
in twenty years and one…

This was an especially poignant song for Price to set, as she lost a baby boy in infancy.

Edward Elgar: Nursery Suite (1931) 

Nursery Suite is one of the last pieces of music that Elgar ever wrote. In 1930, a 73-year-old Elgar told a friend that he’d recently found a box of music in manuscript dating from his youth.

His friend suggested that he work them up into something to celebrate the recent birth of Princess Margaret. He agreed, and by the following year he produced a sweet little orchestral suite with movement titles like “The Sad Doll” and “The Merry Doll.”

Elgar expanded the dedication: the final work was dedicated to Princess Margaret, Princess Elizabeth (the future Elizabeth II), and their mother, the Duchess of York.

Sergei Prokofiev: Peter and the Wolf (1936) 

Peter and the Wolf was commissioned by the director of the Central Children’s Theatre in Moscow. She wanted Prokofiev to write a special symphony for children.

Peter, the work’s protagonist, plays in a meadow, listening to a whole menagerie of animals symbolised by various instruments.

Peter’s grandfather warns him of a gray wolf who might come to attack him. On cue, the wolf makes an appearance. Luckily, with the help of his animal friends, Peter is able to catch it.

Hunters come out of the forest, ready to kill the wolf, but Peter convinces them to put the wolf in a cage and bring it to a zoo instead. They do so in triumphant formation. At the last minute, a quacking comes from the wolf’s stomach: he has eaten the duck whole!

The work has proven to be incredibly popular and enduring, and it is often used even today as an introduction to the orchestra and orchestral instruments.

Benjamin Britten: The Young Person’s Guide to the Orchestra (1945) 

In the mid-1940s, composer Benjamin Britten was commissioned to score an educational documentary called Instruments of the Orchestra.

The main theme comes from another famous British composer: Henry Purcell‘s incidental music to Aphra Behn’s Abdelazer.

Each section shows off a different part of the orchestra, helping young listeners (of all ages!) to appreciate the uniqueness of each one.

Interestingly, there is a version with narration and another one without.

Samuel Barber: Knoxville: Summer of 1915 (1947) 

Samuel Barber’s Knoxville: Summer of 1915 is for orchestra and soprano soloist. It is a nostalgic portrait of the narrator’s childhood.

The lyrics are from a 1938 prose poem by James Agee, describing the summer before his father died in a car accident:

On the rough, wet grass of the back yard, my father and mother have spread quilts. We all lie there, my mother, my father, my uncle, my aunt, and I too am lying there….They are not talking much, and the talk is quiet, of nothing in particular, of nothing at all. The stars are wide and alive, they seem each like a smile of great sweetness, and they seem very near…

Barber’s music beautifully captures the uneasy poignancy of Agee’s words.

Conclusion

So there you have it: ten pieces of classical music about childhood and youth.

Did you have a favorite piece of classical music as a child? Is it still a favorite now? Let us know!