Showing posts with label Emily E. Hogstad. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Emily E. Hogstad. Show all posts

Friday, November 13, 2026

The Best Cello Concertos of Each Decade of the 1800s

  

What you won’t hear about is everything else – and there was a lot of everything else! Across the century, cello concertos were written constantly, just not by the composers we now call great. They were written by touring virtuosos, cellists who needed a vehicle built to their own hands and nobody else’s, and who published their concertos, if they published them at all, almost as an afterthought to the touring.

Today we’re tracing the history of the cello concerto through the 1800s, the century when it came into its own and proved its mettle as one of the great solo instruments of the art.

1800s: Ludwig van Beethoven – Triple Concerto for Violin, Cello, and Piano (1804)  

At the turn of the 19th century, touring cellists usually wrote cello concertos to showcase their virtuosity.

However, in 1804, Beethoven wrote a concerto in which virtuoso fireworks were secondary. In his Triple Concerto, he gave the cello equal billing with the violin and piano – and even gave the work’s opening solo line to the cellist.

Riedel: Beethoven, 1801

Riedel: Beethoven, 1801

Initially, the innovation didn’t land. The Triple Concerto wasn’t premiered until 1808, when audiences were distracted by the Napoleonic Wars, and it struggled to find a foothold. Even today, it is among Beethoven’s least popular concertos.

However, Beethoven’s willingness to treat the cello as a solo instrument in orchestral art music was noted. It opened the door to later giants like Schumann, Saint-Saëns, and Dvořák to write their own cello masterpieces.

1810s: Max Bohrer – Cello Concerto No. 1 (1819)

Max Bohrer

Max Bohrer

Cellist Max Bohrer was born in Munich to a musical family in 1785. By 14, he had joined the court orchestra there. He would later work in the Berlin court orchestra and the Württemberg court orchestra, with a stint in Paris.

He and his brother Antoine, a violinist, toured Europe in a string quartet. (Beethoven was among the contemporary composers they championed.) Sometimes the two co-composed works in Paganini’s bravura style.

In 1819, Max Bohrer wrote a cello concerto. It employs the same opera-inspired language that Paganini’s violin concertos (written around the same time) would draw on. The aim here was less to create an enduring piece of art music, and more to provide a thrilling vehicle for Bohrer’s tours – which, by all accounts, it succeeded brilliantly at.

1820s: Bernhard Romberg – Cello Concerto No. 6 (c. 1820), “Concerto militaire”

Bernhard Romberg

Bernhard Romberg

Bernhard Romberg, born in 1767, was among the most influential cellists of his generation. In 1790, the year he turned 23, he joined the court orchestra of the Archbishop of Cologne in Beethoven’s hometown of Bonn. Beethoven, then 19, admired him and his playing. (His cello writing also inspired Brahms.)

Romberg made important contributions to the cello. He pioneered the Romberg bevel, a lowered fingerboard that lets the C-string vibrate more easily. He also advocated for the construction of ½ and ¾ sized cellos so children could learn.

His sixth cello concerto, subtitled Concerto militaire, is noteworthy for its inclusion of trumpets and timpani sections. It hasn’t entered the standard repertoire, but it proved the cello could hold its own as a solo instrument against an expanded orchestra.

1830s: Adrien-François Servais – Cello Concerto No. 1 in B minor (1834)

Adrien-François Servais

Adrien-François Servais

Adrien-François Servais was born in Halle, near Brussels, in 1807. He began his music studies on the violin before switching to the cello. He won first prize at the Brussels Conservatory in 1829, made his Parisian debut in 1833, and embarked on an international career as a soloist.

Following in Bohrer’s footsteps, he earned the nickname “the Paganini of the cello” from Berlioz and Rossini.

He was the first major cellist to use an endpin instead of squeezing the instrument between his knees.

Servais composed his elegant first cello concerto to use while on tour. Like Bohrer’s work, it drew more on operatic aesthetics than the traditional musical language of Germanic concertos. Servais kept it to himself for many years, only publishing it in 1848.

1840s: Jacques Offenbach – Grand Concerto for cello in G major “Concerto militaire” (1848)

Jacques Offenbach

Jacques Offenbach

Today, Jacques Offenbach is best known for his operettas, but he began his career as a cello virtuoso.

Born in 1819, he studied cello at the Paris Conservatoire and spent years as a working cellist, touring and playing in the Paris Opéra-Comique orchestra.

He dreamed of performing on stage himself and seemed set to break through after presenting satirical works at salons, but those ambitions were delayed in 1848, when the revolution broke out.

In the meantime, he composed this flashy cello concerto, nicknamed the “Concerto militaire.” He never published it, and the parts of the score were dispersed into various libraries and personal collections. A version of the score was recreated in the 1940s, but the authentic version was not rediscovered until the mid-2000s.

1850s: Robert Schumann – Cello Concerto (1850)   

In October 1850, orchestral instruments were on Robert Schumann’s mind, having just arrived in Düsseldorf to serve as the city’s new music director. He wrote his cello concerto in a burst of inspiration and finished it in just two weeks.

He composed the concerto for the sheer love of the game, with no commission and no soloist in mind. He wrote it because “there are so few works for this lovely instrument,” as he said in a letter to a potential publisher.

Robert Schumann (1839)

Robert Schumann (1839)

This origin clearly sets the concerto apart from the work of Bohrer, Romberg, Servais, and Offenbach. It is an early example of the growing divergence between composers and interpreters during the Romantic era.

Its three movements run together without pause, and Schumann kept the cello mostly in its middle and upper register, avoiding virtuosity for virtuosity’s sake. As a result, it is perhaps the earliest 19th-century solo cello concerto to earn a place in the canon.

1860s: Karl Davydov – Cello Concerto No. 3 in D major (1868)

Karl Davydov

Karl Davydov

Karl Davydov was born in 1838 in present-day Latvia. He studied mathematics before turning to music, training as a composer and embarking on a career as a touring cellist.

In 1863, at the age of 25, he became one of the first professors at the St. Petersburg Conservatory; a few years later, he wrote this concerto. It is one of four that he wrote during his career.

None of his concertos entered the Western repertoire. Still, they provide an invaluable insight into what high-level Russian cello playing of the era valued: secure technique paired with fluidity and soaring lyricism. Davydov’s students would go on to influence the development of the cello concerto in the decades to come.

1870s: Camille Saint-Saëns – Cello Concerto in A minor (1872)   

This concerto came at a pivotal moment in French music history. After the Franco-Prussian War, which lasted from July 1870 to January 1871, French composers sought to differentiate themselves from the Austro-German musical tradition.

Different composers reacted to this pressure in different ways. Some abandoned concertos altogether, while Saint-Saëns tried his luck at a uniquely French one: fleet, fluid, flashy, and, importantly, a single movement. Instead of using the traditional Germanic model of a three-movement concerto, Saint-Saëns used a cyclic form – i.e., used the same theme throughout a piece – that Berlioz and Liszt had championed.

Portrait of Camille Saint-Saëns by Benjamin Constant

Portrait of Camille Saint-Saëns by Benjamin Constant

The result was one of the most successful French concertos of the 19th century – and one of the most beloved cello concertos, period.

1880s: Johannes Brahms – Concerto for Violin and Cello (1887)  

Brahms wrote this concerto as a peace offering. He and his longtime friend and colleague, violinist Joseph Joachim, had fallen out in 1883 during Joachim’s divorce. The manuscript was an olive branch.

Joachim accepted it. He and Robert Hausmann, cellist of the Joachim Quartet, contributed and were the soloists at the premiere in 1887. Afterwards, Brahms gave Joachim a copy of the manuscript inscribed with the words “to him for whom it was written.”

The Brahms Double holds a prominent but unusual place in 19th-century cello literature. It shares similarities with the Beethoven Triple concerto: both were the only multi-instrument concerto their respective composers wrote, and both were received relatively coolly.

It also joins the ranks of longer-lived cello concertos in the repertoire written by non-cellists: a space occupied by Saint-Saëns and Brahms’s mentor Schumann.

1890s: Antonín Dvořák – Cello Concerto in B minor (1894–1895)  

Cellist Hanuš Wihan, a friend of Dvořák and a student of Davydov, asked Dvořák for a cello concerto for years.

Dvořák kept turning him down, believing that the cello’s lower and upper registers precluded it from being a successful solo instrument.

Hanuš Wihan

Hanuš Wihan

However, in 1894, he heard cellist-composer Victor Herbert perform his second cello concerto in New York. Dvořák was inspired, and he wrote his own cello concerto in four months between 1894 and 1895.

The concerto became the greatest of the century, and the battle between non-cellists and cellists came to a satisfying conclusion: the great work of a cellist-composer inspired a non-cellist to write the defining cello concerto of the century.

In the end, Dvořák proved once and for all that the cello could indeed take the lead in a Romantic-era concerto.

Antonín Dvořák, 1882

Antonín Dvořák, 1882

Conclusion

Looking back at the century, certain patterns become clear. The concertos written by cellists – Bohrer, Romberg, Servais, Davydov – are virtuosic, opera-inflected, built for the road, and mostly gone from the stage today. Meanwhile, the ones written by outsiders – Beethoven, Schumann, Saint-Saëns, Brahms, and finally Dvořák – are the ones still performed every season.

Together, each one tried to answer the question: could a cello take the starring role in a Romantic-era concerto? A century that began with Beethoven handing the cello an opening solo line closed with Dvořák handing it off to the century’s great masterpiece. Every concerto in between – famous or forgotten – was the argument being made.

Friday, October 30, 2026

How Family Connections Helped These Composers Find Their Wives

 

Today, marrying a cousin is unusual, but throughout history it was hardly unheard of, especially in close-knit families where relatives often lived near one another. The musical world was especially interconnected, and several composers found love within their own extended families.

For Johann Sebastian Bach, Edvard Grieg, and Sergei Rachmaninoff, family connections ultimately led to marriages with cousins, with very different circumstances and consequences.

Other composers found themselves drawn to the sisters of women they’d already fallen in love with – and marrying them.

Here are some fascinating stories of composers whose wives were already part of their family or social circles.

Composers Who Married Their Cousin

Johann Sebastian Bach and Maria Barbara Bach, 1707   

We don’t know when Johann Sebastian Bach met his first wife, Maria Barbara. However, they were second cousins, sharing the same great-grandfather, and the extended Bach family was closely knit, so they likely met through family.

The couple married in 1707, when both Johann and Maria Barbara were 22. They had seven children together, including the composers Wilhelm Friedemann Bach and Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach.

A silhouette of Maria Barbara Bach

A silhouette of Maria Barbara Bach

Their marriage ended tragically. In the summer of 1720, Johann went on a business trip, accompanying his employer, Prince Leopold of Anhalt-Köthen, to the Karlsbad spa. When he returned, Maria Barbara was dead and had already been buried. We don’t know what she died of.

We looked at what happened to all of Bach’s children with Maria Barbara: https://interlude.hk/what-happened-to-bachs-twenty-children/.

Edvard Grieg and Nina Hagerup, 1867   

Edvard Grieg and Nina Hagerup’s mothers were sisters, so Edvard and Nina met each other young in their hometown of Bergen, Norway. In 1853, when Nina was eight years old, her family moved to Copenhagen, separating the two children.

A decade later, Edvard also moved to Copenhagen to study music. There, he began meeting Nina, who by then had become a talented soprano.

Edvard Grieg and Nina Hagerup Grieg

Edvard Grieg and Nina Hagerup Grieg

The two fell in love, and in late 1864, Edvard proposed. Their engagement lasted for nearly three years, and neither side of their family was happy about the match, as Grieg’s economic prospects were considered uncertain.

Still, they married anyway in 1867, and despite their rough patches, they became partners in both life and music until his death.

Sergei Rachmaninoff and Natalya Satina, 1902   

Rachmaninoff was a musically precocious child. In 1885, when he was twelve, he moved in with his piano teacher, as was custom for serious students at the time.

However, four years later, after Rachmaninoff asked for more access to a piano to practice and compose and his teacher turned him down, he began looking for new lodgings.

Sergei Rachmaninoff and Natalia Satina

Sergei Rachmaninoff and Natalia Satina

He decided to move in with the Satin family, his paternal aunt’s family. He became part of the household, even travelling with them to their private country estate in the summer of 1890. During that time, he became close to their daughter Natalya, who was also a pianist. He would eventually fall in love with her.

Rachmaninoff’s musical career kicked off in earnest during the 1890s, leading him to consider starting a family; in 1899, he and Natalya became engaged. It was a problematic match, as the Orthodox Church forbade cousins from marrying, and a dispensation from the Tsar was necessary.

Finally, in April 1902, after a three-year engagement, Rachmaninoff and Natalya decided to marry in a military barracks, because the priests there answered to military officials rather than the Church itself.

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart and Constanze Weber, 1782    

In 1777, 21-year-old Mozart left his hometown of Salzburg to look for work. He stopped in Mannheim and met the musical Weber family, whose four daughters were talented musicians.

Mozart eventually fell in love with one of them – the 17-year-old soprano Aloysia Weber – but she was uninterested in him.

Constanze Mozart

Constanze Mozart

His path crossed with the Webers again in 1781. In the intervening years, the family had moved to Vienna for Aloysia’s singing career. Their patriarch had died, so to support themselves, they took in roomers – including Mozart.

While there, his affections transferred to Aloysia’s sister Constanze. Wolfgang and Constanze fell in love and married in August 1782. Despite the initial disapproval of their families, they enjoyed a happy marriage until his death.  

As a young man, Joseph Haydn was hired to teach music to the family of Johann Keller, a wealthy Viennese wigmaker.

Haydn fell in love with one of Johann’s daughters, Theresia Keller. However, their romantic connection was immediately threatened by Joseph and Theresia’s difference in wealth (Haydn had not yet secured his position as a court composer), as well as her parents’ fierce Catholicism; they wanted Theresia to become a nun.

Maria Anna Keller

Maria Anna Keller

Obeying their wishes, Theresia entered a convent in 1755 and took her vows the following year. Haydn wrote an Organ Concerto in C major for the ceremony of her profession as Sister Josepha.

Five years later, after Haydn secured his first position and looked for a wife, he returned to the Kellers. Although he didn’t love her, he married Theresia’s older sister Maria Anna.

They discovered quickly that they were a bad match. Joseph famously wrote with scorn, “She doesn’t care a straw whether her husband is an artist or a cobbler.” In addition, Maria Anna was apparently unable to bear children, which Haydn held against her.

The Haydns never reconciled, and they lived apart until Maria Anna died in 1800.

Antonín Dvořák and Anna Čermáková, 1873   In the 1860s, up-and-coming musician Antonín Dvořák was struggling to pay his bills. He began giving piano lessons, and two of his students were two sisters from the Čermáková family: Josefína (born in 1849) and Anna (born in 1854).

Josefína became an actress and joined the Prague Provisional Theatre in 1862. Dvořák was in the orchestra and fell in love with her. However, she was uninterested in him and wanted to focus on her career (she eventually married Count Václav Robert of Kounice in 1877).

Anna Cermakova and Dvořák

Anna Cermakova and Dvořák

Instead, Dvořák began dating her younger sister Anna, and he married her in November 1873.

Unlike Haydn’s, this marriage was warm. Anna turned into a force behind Dvořák’s career, pushing him to work in America for the money – without which we wouldn’t have masterpieces like the New World Symphony or the “American” string quartet.

Dvořák, Anna, and Josefina remained close (in fact, Dvořák was the best man at her wedding). When Josefina was dying of heart trouble in the 1890s, he wrote a tribute to her in his cello concerto, quoting one of her favourite songs of his. It was a love song not only to her but to the entire close-knit family.


Conclusion

These stories reveal how interconnected musicians’ personal and professional worlds could be. In several cases, family connections led composers to find their lifelong partners and, often, important musical collaborators and supporters.

The stories of the composers who married their love interests’ sisters are more varied, between Mozart and Dvořák’s happiness and Haydn’s unhappiness.

Their stories show that sometimes in classical music history, love emerged from the closest possible circles – and also that being part of the same family wasn’t necessarily a guarantee of a happy marriage.

If You Love the “Great” Composers, You’ll Love These Women Composers Too

 by Emily E. Hogstad  October 25th, 2026


But women composers were also composing at the same time. They were writing symphonies, tone poems, concertos, operas, and overtures in the same styles, often studying with the same teachers. And yet their work didn’t enter the repertoire in the same way, despite its obvious quality.

Here are seven connections between the orchestral works of great men composers and great women composers.

Louise Farrenc’s Symphony No. 3 (1847)   

Louise Farrenc was born in Paris in 1804.

One of her teachers was pianist Ignaz Moscheles, who taught Felix Mendelssohn and his sister Fanny.

Farrenc also studied with Anton Reicha, Hector Berlioz’s composition teacher – giving her an impressive resume all around.

Louise Farrenc

Louise Farrenc

French composers of Farrenc’s generation were encouraged to focus their highest ambitions on writing theatre music and opera, not symphonies. Even Berlioz, arguably the greatest French composer of his generation, wrote only four, none of them a conventional symphony.

Farrenc wrote three. Her elegant third symphony is perhaps her best, with its dramatic G-minor opening movement and fairy-like scherzo, reminiscent of the writing in Mendelssohn’s overture to A Midsummer Night’s Dream (at 25:15 in the video above).   

Emilie Mayer was born in 1812 in Germany. A couple of years later, her mother died. Then, in 1840, her father died by suicide on the anniversary of her mother’s burial. He left Emilie enough money to live on, enabling her to do what she wanted with her life.

She had studied music as a young person and pursued it as a devoted amateur throughout her early adulthood. But after her father’s death, she chose to make a new start, throwing herself into studying music at a professional level.

Emilie Mayer

Emilie Mayer

During this time, she studied with music theorist Adolph Bernhard Marx, who was close to the Mendelssohn family and a music critic and colleague of Robert Schumann’s.

Like many Germans of her generation, she was deeply inspired by drama and literature. She later wrote an overture to Faust in 1880, echoing Robert Schumann’s fascination with the great writer and his oratorio-like work Scenes from Goethe’s Faust.

Mayer’s fourth symphony embodies this appreciation for drama and psychological complexity; it’s especially noticeable in the first movement, with its growling trills and timpani rolls.

Augusta Holmès was born in 1847 in Paris to Irish parents. She was a musical child, but her gender kept her from enrolling at the Paris Conservatoire.

She became a fan of Liszt in 1861, when she was just thirteen. At 21, she travelled to Munich to see the premiere of Wagner’s Das Rheingold. While there, she met and befriended Franz Liszt, who was impressed by her work, and they began corresponding by letter.

Like Liszt, she gravitated toward big, bold tone poems over symphonies. Her symphonic poem Andromède follows the story of Andromeda, daughter of a king who is chained to a rock and sacrificed to the sea in the hope that the sea monster Cetus will stop ravaging the coastline. Holmès evokes the wind and waves in her tone poem, as well as the thrill of her eventual rescue.

She also wrote symphonic poems on nationalist themes, such as Irlande (Ireland) and Pologne (Poland), calling to mind Liszt’s Hungarian Rhapsodies.   

Amy Beach was born in 1867 in New Hampshire. She was an impressive child prodigy, starting to compose at the age of four. She became a piano virtuoso as a teenager and was encouraged to study in Europe to take her career to the next level, but she opted to stay in America.

At 18, she married a wealthy Boston doctor. It would have been insulting to him to make money as a performer while married, so she limited her performances to charity performances and began focusing on composing instead.

Amy Beach

Amy Beach

In November 1892, two months after arriving in America to lead the National Conservatory of Music, composer Antonín Dvořák gave a controversial interview published in the Boston Post, claiming that women could be fine interpreters but not great creators. In December, Amy Beach wrote a rebuttal, citing dozens of great works written by women.

Shortly after this exchange, both composers soon embarked on the defining symphony of their careers.

In January 1893, Dvořák began writing his ninth symphony, later known as the New World; Beach attended the Boston premiere. She heard that Dvořák was clearly inspired by Black folk music and noted it, but, given her ancestry, she felt more drawn to use Gaelic folk music.

Within the year, she began writing her own folk-inspired symphony, which came to be known as the Gaelic Symphony. It demonstrated – pointedly – that Dvořák’s ideas about women’s inability to write music were wrong.   

Ethel Smyth was born in London in 1858 and became famous for being a musician and a suffragette. Against her family’s wishes, she left England to study music in Germany as a young woman and eventually became a professional composer.

In 1877, she went to see Wagner conduct, later describing him as “an undersized man with a huge head, apparently in a towering rage from start to finish of the concert.”

Ethel Smyth

Ethel Smyth

Despite that wry description, she took inspiration from Wagner while writing opera. In her creative life, she veered away from stereotypically feminine qualities and toward stereotypically masculine ones, specialising in big, bold writing for brass sections and large, loud orchestral writing.

This emotionally expressive, Wagnerian style was on full display in her 1906 opera The Wreckers.

Ina Boyle was born in Ireland in 1889. She began studying music at home with her governess, then took composition lessons in Dublin.

In 1923, she began studying with British composer Ralph Vaughan Williams. She took sea voyages to see him and also took lessons by correspondence. She kept those letters in a folder labelled “Letters from my beloved teacher, Dr Ralph Vaughan Williams O.M., from 1923 to 1938.”

Ina Boyle

Ina Boyle

She wrote her violin concerto between 1932 and 1933. Its soaring, yearning string lines call to mind her teacher’s celebrated 1910 work for string orchestra, Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis.

Boyle’s lessons with Vaughan Williams ended when World War II began. She remained in Ireland, isolated from peers, but continued composing daily: a purity of intention and love for the art that few other composers, “great” or not, can match.  Grażyna Bacewicz was born in 1909 in Łódź, Poland, into a musical family. She learned to play piano and violin, and at thirteen, she began composing.

She became known for her violin playing and was named concertmaster of the Polish National Radio Symphony Orchestra in the 1930s.

She also kept composing, experimenting with the neoclassical style then in vogue. In 1932, she took composition lessons with Nadia Boulanger, the same teacher who had taught Igor Stravinsky, then famous for his own neoclassical works.

Grażyna Bacewicz

Grażyna Bacewicz

During World War II, she moved to Warsaw and performed in underground concerts there. In 1944, during the Warsaw Uprising, she fled to Lublin.

The politically restrictive environment in Poland in the mid-1940s was not conducive to aesthetic experimentation, and Bacewicz stuck close to the neoclassical style she’d first embraced in the 1930s.

Her 1948 Concerto for String Orchestra is fiercely confident, driven by propulsive rhythms that recall Stravinsky’s own carefully structured neoclassical works.

However, while Stravinsky’s neoclassicism can sometimes feel detached or ironic, Bacewicz’s approach ultimately comes across as more rooted and emotionally expressive.

Conclusion

All seven of these women created extraordinary work that should never have been dismissed or forgotten.

All of their achievements are remarkable. Farrenc wrote three symphonies in a genre the French establishment tended to dismiss, despite the symphony’s importance to music history generally. Beach not only publicly advocated for women composers but demonstrated their talent in her work. Boyle kept writing music after she was cut off from her teacher and everyone outside of Ireland.

Each of them took the same forms, the same influences, and the same historical moment, and blended those ingredients to make something distinct enough that their works still sound like their own. Listeners deserve to hear everything they did, regardless of whether historians, critics, and gatekeepers label them “great” or not.

Monday, October 26, 2026

The Passionate Stories of Composers Starstruck By Their Wives

 by 

A performance, a chance meeting, a dinner party, or even a single conversation could leave these men completely captivated – and sometimes they moved fast between fascination, courtship, and marriage.

What makes these stories especially fascinating is how often the women who captured their attention were great artists themselves. Actresses, singers, pianists, sculptors, and composers became not only their wives but also creative collaborators, muses, interpreters, and sometimes accomplished artists in their own right.

Here are some remarkable composer marriages that feature especially starstruck husbands.

Composers Who Married Women They Fell In Love With at First Sight

Hector Berlioz and Harriet Smithson, 1833

Berlioz’s Symphonie fantastique, 1830  

The most famous example of a composer falling in love at first sight is surely French composer Hector Berlioz.

In 1827, the 23-year-old composer watched Irish actress Harriet Smithson play Ophelia with an English-language touring theatre troupe. Her craft magnetised him – along with the rest of Paris.

Martinet rue du Coq St Honoré: Harriet Smithson as Ophelia in Hamlet, 1827–1833 (Bibliothèque nationale de France, département Musique)

Martinet rue du Coq St Honoré: Harriet Smithson as Ophelia in Hamlet, 1827–1833 (Bibliothèque nationale de France, département Musique)

He began sending her love letters in French (she didn’t – and couldn’t – answer), and even moved in across the street from her lodgings to monitor her comings and goings.

That spirit of unrequited obsession found its way into his 1830 Symphonie Fantastique, a programmatic symphony about a lovesick artist who descends into a drug-fueled reverie.

Hector Berlioz and Harriet Smithson

Hector Berlioz and Harriet Smithson

His obsession with Smithson inspired the use of a technique known as the idée fixe – a theme heard in various guises throughout the work, standing in for the idea of the beloved.

Understandably, Smithson initially stayed away from Berlioz for quite a while. But after some time had passed, and she attended a performance of the symphony, she became intrigued by the composer who had written such bold music about her. They began dating and eventually married in 1833.


Gustav Mahler and Alma Schindler, 1902

Mahler’s Adagietto from Symphony No. 5, 1901–1902   

Gustav Mahler had a similar epiphany in early November 1901 upon meeting Alma Schindler, a 22-year-old aspiring composer at a Viennese dinner party. They got into a quick-witted sparring match about music and beauty.

Although he was nearly twice her age, his physical attraction to her was overwhelming. At this time, Mahler was arguably the most famous musician in Vienna, serving as the music director at the court opera, and he invited Alma and her family to visit him there the following day.

Alma and Gustav Mahler with their children

Alma and Gustav Mahler with their children

They’d met on 7 November 1901. Less than three weeks later, he was talking to her as if the question of their getting married was already settled.

They announced their engagement on 27 December and began sleeping together shortly afterwards. She became pregnant quickly, and they married on 9 March 1902.


Felix Mendelssohn and Cécile Jeanrenaud, 1837

Mendelssohn’s Paulus, 1836     

Felix Mendelssohn’s love thunderbolt was less scandalous than Berlioz and Mahler’s – but no less impactful.

On 4 May 1836, while visiting Frankfurt, he stepped in to conduct a choir for a friend who had fallen ill. There he was introduced to soprano Cécile Jeanrenaud, the young unmarried daughter of a pastor.

Cécile Charlotte Sophie Mendelssohn Bartholdy (née Jeanrenaud, 1817–1853)

Cécile Charlotte Sophie Mendelssohn Bartholdy (née Jeanrenaud, 1817–1853)

He was deeply taken with her and could not get her out of his mind. A couple of days later, he left Frankfurt for Düsseldorf to oversee the premiere of his oratorio Paulus. After that, he travelled to the Dutch seaside town of Scheveningen, preoccupied by thoughts of Cécile and weighing whether to return to Frankfurt.

On 7 June 1836, he did. Three months later, he proposed to her while on a picnic. She said yes, and they were married in March of 1837.


Composers Who Married a Prominent Artist

Robert Schumann and Clara Wieck, 1840

Robert Schumann’s Widmung, 1840  

In 1828, 17-year-old Robert Schumann, newly arrived in Leipzig to study law, saw 8-year-old piano prodigy Clara Wieck perform at a house concert.

He was deeply impressed by what he saw – so much so that he ultimately gave up studying law and moved in with Clara’s father, Friedrich, to study piano with him.

He and Clara became friends in between her international tours, as he found his voice as a musician and ultimately composer. Eventually, they fell in love.

Robert and Clara Schumann, daguerreotype

Robert and Clara Schumann, daguerreotype

Friedrich, however, fought against the match – ferociously. The family ended up in court. They finally achieved legal permission to wed, and on 12 September 1840, the day before her 21st birthday, they were married.

Clara went on to become one of the great pianists of the 19th century, integral to both Schumann’s creativity and the promotion of his work after he died in 1856.


Carl Nielsen and Anne Marie Brodersen, 1891

Nielsen’s Symphony No. 1, 1891–1892  

On 2 March 1891, while Danish composer Carl Nielsen was studying in Paris, he met a sculptor and fellow Dane named Anne Marie Brodersen. He was intrigued by her from the start, writing in his diary that she was “really quite pretty.” They went out to the Moulin Rouge, where they danced together past two in the morning.

Anne Marie Carl-Nielsen working on a sculpture

Anne Marie Carl-Nielsen working on a sculpture

Eighteen days later, they “considered themselves married.” They had a party celebrating their union on 10 April and made it legal on 10 May in Florence during a whirlwind Italian honeymoon.

Unlike many women artists of her generation, she continued working even after her marriage. She became one of the most prominent Danish sculptors of the early 20th century.

That career strained their relationship, and they endured several periods of separation. (Nielsen even had a child out of wedlock with another woman that she never found out about.) They ultimately reconciled…even if they never rediscovered the emotional intimacy they’d once enjoyed.

Richard Strauss and Pauline de Ahna, 1894

Strauss’s “Morgen”, 1894      

Richard Strauss met soprano Pauline de Ahna in Munich in 1887. He was 23 – just over a year older than her – but despite his youth, he’d already won a position as music director of the Bavarian State Opera, and he began giving her vocal lessons.

They worked together professionally for years. In 1894, she was cast in the premiere of Strauss’s first opera, Guntram.

Pauline de Ahna

Pauline de Ahna

During one rehearsal that May, he corrected the tenor multiple times, as de Ahna grew increasingly irritated. Eventually she started screaming at Strauss that she wanted to be interrupted, too – and threw her vocal score at him before storming offstage. He excused himself to confer with her, then returned to the podium to announce that they were engaged.

Their marriage was long and happy. Although she retired from the operatic stage in 1897 after the birth of their only son, she continued performing his works, inspiring many of them, until 1948’s Four Last Songs.


Olivier Messiaen and Claire Delbos, 1932, and Yvonne Loriod, 1961

Messiaen’s Thème et variations, 1932   

Over the course of his life, composer Olivier Messiaen married two great artists.

He met his first wife, violinist and composer Claire Delbos, in the 1920s while studying at the Paris Conservatoire. They became recital partners, fell in love, and married in 1932.

Her reproductive health suffered during the marriage, and she had a series of miscarriages; only their son Pascal, born in 1937, survived.

Claire Delbos and Olivier Messiaen in Neussargues-Moissac

Claire Delbos and Olivier Messiaen in Neussargues-Moissac

In 1949, when she was 43, her recovery from a hysterectomy went wrong, resulting in a cerebral infection that in turn caused severe brain damage and amnesia. She lived the final ten years of her life in an institution.

In the early 1940s, Messiaen taught a talented pianist named Yvonne Loriod and even wrote works for her to play. Their intense creative relationship raised eyebrows and eventually evolved into something romantic – but, being devout Catholics, they remained celibate, even after Delbos’s institutionalisation. They only married in 1961, two years after Delbos’s death.

Yvonne Loriod and Olivier Messiaen

Yvonne Loriod and Olivier Messiaen

Loriod remained Messiaen’s primary inspiration and greatest interpreter until he died.


Conclusion

Regardless of what ultimately happened in their relationships, all these composers had early encounters with their wives that proved to be more than a fleeting attraction.

In many cases, the woman who initially captivated them became deeply intertwined with their creative lives. Harriet Smithson inspired one of the most famous musical portraits of romantic obsession; Clara Wieck became an essential interpreter of Robert Schumann’s music; Pauline de Ahna championed Richard Strauss’s works for decades; and Yvonne Loriod ultimately became Olivier Messiaen’s greatest interpreter.

Of course, love at first sight did not guarantee an uncomplicated marriage. Some of these relationships endured happily for decades, while others were marked by separation, infidelity, illness, or profound personal hardship.

But they all began with the same extraordinary initial experience: a composer encountering a talented woman who was impossible to forget.

For more of the best in classical music, sign up for our E-Newsletter