Showing posts with label Felix Mendelsohn - Bartholdy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Felix Mendelsohn - Bartholdy. Show all posts

Friday, November 6, 2026

The Best Symphony of Each Decade of the 1800s

  

The form entered the century as a genteel curtain-raiser: twenty minutes of Classical politeness, often featuring courtly, aristocratic minuets.

It left the century capable of embodying autobiography, nationalist argument, spiritual crisis, and philosophical statement – sometimes all at once, and sometimes for the better part of two hours.

This list traces that transformation decade by decade, picking the symphony that did the most to move the genre forward.

1800s – Beethoven, Symphony No. 3, “Eroica” (1803–1804)   

Beethoven’s third symphony broke the rules the genre had followed for decades. Before 1804, symphonies were expected to last between twenty and thirty minutes. However, Beethoven’s Third lasts nearly fifty minutes. Its opening movement alone is longer than many of Haydn’s and Mozart’s symphonies.

Christian Hornemann: Ludwig von Beethoven, 1803

Christian Hornemann: Ludwig von Beethoven, 1803

That massive first movement isn’t the only stand-out moment in the work. The second movement is a dramatic funeral march; the third a beefy scherzo with three horns; and the finale is a massive set of variations on a theme.

That doesn’t even touch on the extramusical story of the work. It was originally meant to be a tribute to Napoleon. Still, after Napoleon declared himself emperor in 1804, Beethoven was furious and struck out the symphony’s nickname so violently that he tore a hole in the title page.

It was a fittingly dramatic coda to the creation of a work that went on to shape the rest of the 19th century.

1810s – Beethoven, Symphony No. 7 (1811–1812)   

Beethoven’s Third permitted symphonists to dream bigger, but his Seventh let them find inspiration in one of music’s smallest, most basic elements: rhythm.

Each movement of Beethoven’s Seventh showcases a different, insistent pulse. The first movement uses swinging, dotted rhythms; the second, hushed funereal march rhythms; the third, bouncy presto rhythms; and the fourth, swirling sforzandos on dazzling fly-by sixteenth notes.

As different as each movement is, this focus on rhythm lends coherence to the entire work.

Richard Wagner called this symphony “the apotheosis of the dance.” It gave future composers a blueprint for building large-scale orchestral works around rhythmic drive rather than melody alone.

1820s – Beethoven, Symphony No. 9 (1822–1824)    

You might be thinking, Beethoven again? But it’s undeniable: for three decades in a row, Beethoven composed what is unquestionably the most important symphony of the decade.

Beethoven’s ninth (and final) symphony is where he pushed himself furthest creatively. First, it outpaced even the Third Symphony in length, taking around 70 minutes to perform.

More consequentially, he created a final movement scored for orchestra and voices, setting a text from Schiller’s Ode to Joy in an ecstatic celebration of universal brotherhood.

Beethoven’s Ninth has reverberated ever since. Mahler answered Beethoven directly, writing choral symphonies of his own. Brahms avoided choral writing in his symphonies entirely, aiming to prove a purely orchestral symphony alone could pack the same punch. Meanwhile, Wagner found the Ninth so overwhelming he came to believe it marked the culmination – and the end – of purely instrumental music and turned to opera instead.

This symphony isn’t just influential for how it sounds; it’s influential for the ideas it unleashed.

1830s – Berlioz, Symphonie Fantastique (1830)       

Berlioz heard Beethoven’s Ninth in 1828 and was deeply inspired. Two years later, he took the form a step further, giving his own symphony an overt narrative.

Inspired by his obsession with Shakespearean actress Harriet Smithson, the Fantastique tells the (suspiciously autobiographical) story of a drug-fueled artist obsessing over a woman. The story ends with the artist’s execution and a witches’ sabbath.

The young Hector Berlioz

The young Hector Berlioz

In the symphony, Berlioz uses a device called an idée fixe, a single melody that recurs and mutates across all five movements. It grants the symphony a new kind of unity: narrative rather than purely structural or rhythmic.

The orchestration was also groundbreaking, calling for col legno bowing (string playing that uses the wooden part of the bow), offstage oboe, and church bells.

The flash and colour of Berlioz’s storytelling and orchestration inspired composers for the rest of the century, from Liszt’s symphonic poems to the psychological programs of Tchaikovsky’s later symphonies.

1840s – Mendelssohn, Symphony No. 3, “Scottish” (1829–1842)   

After Berlioz’s fever dream of a symphony, Mendelssohn wrote one that also embraced the idea of thematic material transforming from movement to movement.

However, where Berlioz aimed for narrative, flash, and spectacle, Mendelssohn focused on atmosphere and control, proving the two impulses could coexist within Romanticism rather than compete. Even the symphony’s structural innovation – having each movement performed without any break in between – is inextricably linked to the fact that the work employs the traditional four-movement structure.

Eduard Magnus: Felix Mendelssohn, 1846 (Berlin State Library)

Eduard Magnus: Felix Mendelssohn, 1846 (Berlin State Library)

In the end, Mendelssohn’s third became a model for composers who wanted emotional impact without completely abandoning convention.

The “Scottish” took Mendelssohn thirteen years to finish. He began it after visiting a ruined chapel at Holyrood, Scotland, during his European Grand Tour in 1829.

“In the deep twilight we went today to the palace where Queen Mary lived and loved… The chapel below is now roofless… Everything is ruined, decayed, and the clear heavens pour in. I think I have found there the beginning of my ‘Scottish’ Symphony.”

Although he may have found the beginning there, he didn’t finish it until 1842.

1850s – Schumann, Symphony No. 3, “Rhenish” (1850)   

Robert Schumann wrote this symphony in a five-week burst in the fall of 1850, between November 2 and December 9. Although it was the last symphony he completed, it’s numbered as his third.

Schumann gravitated naturally toward songwriting throughout his career, and that instinct shaped his symphonic writing too. He admired how Mendelssohn had folded songlike, lyrical melodies into orchestral form, and he used that device in his own symphonies.

Robert Schumann

Robert Schumann

That same instinct extended to a taste for storytelling, though Schumann resisted attaching an explicit program the way Berlioz had. Instead, the “Rhenish” suggests its story rather than narrating it: the second movement evokes the Rhine River, and the fourth movement portrays a “solemn ceremony,” inspired by an archbishop’s elevation to cardinal at Cologne Cathedral, which Schumann had witnessed in person.

Where Beethoven had expanded the symphony in his third and ninth symphonies by making its four movements longer, Schumann expanded it by adding a fifth movement outright – treating movement count itself as a variable, rather than a fixed convention, to be adjusted to fit the material.

That precedent gave later composers room to do the same: Mahler, working within an even more flexible sense of symphonic structure, would take that same license further.

1860s – Tchaikovsky, Symphony No. 1, “Winter Dreams” (1866–1868)   

The 1860s were a quiet stretch, symphonically speaking. Brahms was a decade into writing his first symphony but paralysed by Beethoven’s enormous shadow. Meanwhile, Bruckner, Borodin, and Dvořák were still young men finding their voices.

A 26-year-old Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky stepped into that gap. Tchaikovsky, a recent graduate of the St. Petersburg Conservatory, wrote his first symphony while suffering something close to a breakdown from insomnia and overwork.

Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky at 23

Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky at 23

He revised it twice over the following years, never fully satisfied.

What survives is the first symphony by a Russian composer to enter the standard modern repertoire. Although Tchaikovsky’s later symphonies ultimately overshadowed it, this first one is important, proving that the German-Austrian tradition wasn’t the only path to symphonic legitimacy.

1870s – Brahms, Symphony No. 1 (1854–1876)   Play

Brahms began sketching this symphony in the 1850s and didn’t finish it for over twenty years, paralysed by the idea that any symphony he wrote would be compared to Beethoven’s.

He was right to be nervous about the inevitable comparisons, because they came. In fact, when it finally did premiere, in 1876, a conductor dubbed it “Beethoven’s Tenth” – fortunately for Brahms, meant as a compliment.

The symphony’s Beethovenian C minor-to-C major trajectory, its finale’s echo of the “Ode to Joy” theme, and its sheer structural and technical rigour all read as a direct answer to Beethoven.

Johannes Brahms, 1866

Johannes Brahms, 1866

Brahms was working against another headwind too: Liszt and Wagner’s flashy new symphonic poems and music dramas were making the case that the old purely instrumental forms Brahms treasured were becoming obsolete.

Brahms’s success with this work breathed new life into a form that Liszt and Wagner had all but declared obsolete.

1880s – Dvořák, Symphony No. 7 (1885)   

Antonín Dvořák came up with the idea for the first movement of his Seventh Symphony after seeing a train of Czech men travelling to Prague to perform at the National Theatre.

Dvořák was inspired to write a serious intellectual work that would depict the drama of the national struggle for independence while being imbued with Czech character.

Antonín Dvořák, 1882

Antonín Dvořák, 1882

His most famous symphony is the Ninth Symphony, nicknamed the “New World.” But that popularity has eclipsed many of his other works, including the seventh. Musicologist Donald Tovey called his seventh “among the greatest and purest examples in this art-form since Beethoven.”

Dvořák’s seventh also contained an unspoken, extramusical argument: that Czech composers like him could use the symphony – widely seen as a primarily Austro-German art form – to express nationalist ideas and emotions.

Between the 1860s and 1880s, Tchaikovsky and Dvořák proved that nationalist identity wasn’t a limitation on the symphony. Still, a source of new vitality – a tradition Sibelius and Shostakovich would carry into the 20th century.

1890s – Mahler, Symphony No. 2 (1888–1894)  

Mahler’s second symphony doesn’t close out the century so much as it kicks the door open to the next one.

Subtitled the “Resurrection”, it runs for nearly ninety minutes, demanding a massive orchestra, offstage brass, a soprano and alto soloist, and a full chorus that doesn’t enter until the final movement, where it sings a text written in part by Mahler himself.

Emil Orlík: Gustav Mahler, 1902

Emil Orlík: Gustav Mahler, 1902

The symphony’s use of the human voice, its willingness to confront death and resurrection head-on as explicit textual subject matter, and its refusal to resolve neatly within Classical proportions all point away from the 19th century and squarely toward the next one.

That expanded sense of what a symphony could be – part autobiography, part spectacle, part spiritual reckoning – became the inheritance every 20th-century symphonist had to reckon with.

Conclusion

Line up all ten choices and a pattern appears that no single entry reveals on its own: the story of the 19th-century symphony is the story of composers answering their predecessors, one symphony at a time.

Beethoven answered Haydn and Mozart by making the form bigger and stranger. Berlioz answered Beethoven by making it explicitly personal. Brahms answered Beethoven, but it took him twenty years of honing his creative powers. Mahler wrote such long, complicated works that he seemed to answer everyone at once.

Sibelius, Shostakovich, and the rest of the 20th century’s symphonists inherited a form so thoroughly reinvented that “symphony” stopped meaning any one thing – and started meaning everything.

Thursday, October 22, 2026

Between Rooms, Between Worlds Marina Baranova on Music, Collaboration, and Curiosity

  


“As a child, I loved moving from room to room,” Baranova says. One space was dominated by classical repertoire, where she listened to her mother and her students work through pieces. “That music always turned into a kind of film in my head, full of depth and emotional intensity.” Classical music, she explains, shaped her early understanding of musical structure, storytelling, and emotional expression.

Marina Baranova

Marina Baranova

In another room, her father was immersed in jazz. “It expressed freedom, rebellion, and creativity without borders,” Baranova recalls. Jazz was forbidden in the Soviet Union, and her father’s involvement with it carried personal and political significance. “The fact that my father played it was, in itself, an act of resistance. You could feel that defiance directly in the sound.”

Growing up with these contrasting musical languages shaped Baranova’s view of genre. “Music has many faces, yet everything can exist under the same roof,” she says. “I like to think of musical genres as different rooms in one house. Each has its own atmosphere, but there is always a door connecting them.”

Maurice Ravel’s Pavane pour une infante défunte, M. 19  

Baranova’s recent recording projects reflect her interest in connection and contrast. Last year, she released Salon de Ravel and The Star of Mendelssohn, two albums with distinctly different conceptual frameworks. “They may appear very different at first glance,” she notes, “yet both come from my musical curiosity.”

Marina Baranova’s Prélude a la manière de Ravel   

Salon de Ravel was inspired by an imagined artistic environment in Paris around 1900. “I pictured Ravel surrounded by musicians, painters, and poets, sharing ideas and new works,” Baranova explains. The album reflects her interest in artistic exchange and influence, particularly the composers Ravel admired, including Borodin, Chabrier, Debussy, and Fauré.

The Star of Mendelssohn, by contrast, has a more personal foundation. The album intertwines Mendelssohn’s Songs Without Words with traditional Christmas carols. “It was conceived as a bridge between worlds,” Baranova says, drawing on her experience of growing up with a Jewish background and later embracing Christian holiday traditions. She also sees parallels in Mendelssohn’s own life. “It mirrors the dualities shaped by multiple traditions.”

That idea of openness and exchange also defines her collaboration with her husband, composer and visual artist Damian Marhulets. The two met when they were twenty and have shared an ongoing artistic dialogue ever since. “We’ve never stopped talking about what it means to be an artist,” Baranova says, describing conversations that range from aesthetics to creative process.

Felix Mendelssohn/Marina Baranova’s Drinking Song, Op. 75 No. 3  

She often plays new piano works for Marhulets, using their discussions as a way to test and refine ideas. “Those conversations are incredibly inspiring and often open doors I didn’t even know were there.” After a recording is completed, Marhulets frequently creates visual artwork in response to the music. “He approaches the music from a different angle, and his visual interpretation uncovers layers I hadn’t seen before,” she says.

Marina Baranova’s The Sense of Cohesion  

In recent years, Baranova has expanded her role beyond performing and recording by curating her own music salon at Villa Seligmann in Hannover, a center dedicated to Jewish music and culture. After renting a studio in the building, she began organising intimate concerts for small audiences. “From the very beginning, I dreamed of creating a music salon,” she says.

The project quickly grew into the ImproVision Festival, developed in collaboration with Villa Seligmann. The festival brings together international musicians to improvise, perform repertoire, and present original works. One highlight was an improvised twelve-hands performance on two pianos shaped by audience suggestions. “It was full of spontaneity and connection,” Baranova recalls.

When Baranova sits at the piano today, she describes the creative impulse as constantly changing. “Each time, the approach feels different,” she says. Sometimes she begins with improvisation, while at other times a connection emerges through sight-reading. “It can feel like a dialogue across time.”

Music also serves a personal function. “Sometimes music feels like a kind of embrace,” she says. “I often feel that new music already exists somewhere, waiting to be given sound.” Honesty, she emphasises, is central to her work. “I only create when the impulse comes from the deepest place within me. I cannot lie in front of music.”

Currently, her piano showcases her diverse interests. Beethoven scores sit next to handwritten sketches for a reworking of Sweeney Todd, originally by Stephen Sondheim. As she says, it’s “a very unlikely house share: Beethoven on one side, Sondheim on the other.” To learn more about Marina Baranova, visit her website at www.marinabaranova.com.

Friday, March 20, 2026

Why Can’t Classical Music Look Ahead

  

In the United Kingdom only, a quick skim through current musical programmes allows one to assess that most of the music performed in concert halls focuses on past composers. Surely, the amount of living composers has never been greater. Especially in the United Kingdom. Yet, all major events, such as the BBC Proms, focus on the past. The old sells. The last night of the Proms in 2025 will see Mussorgsky, Hummel, Gounod, Dukas and of course Britten and Elgar, and many others.

But it is not just in the United Kingdom, opera houses around the world often focus their seasons on a composer of choice, focusing on the catalogue and looking at less famous works. These are still the works of past composers. In 2025, it is Puccini and Handel who will take the frontline at the Paris Opéra.

Opera house

© opera-diary.com

Out of all the currently living composers, very few are allowed the entrance to concert halls pre-mortem, it seems. They are, for most of them, only allowed in the smaller venues. And when they get the keys to the major houses, it is only after years of battling for a place with their ancestors.

However, this has not always been the case historically. Just like popular music today, classical music used to be focused on the new, on composers working towards getting commissions and progressing, on music that was being created in the moment.

Composers were not expected to live off the same material forever, but rather to come up with new and exciting music. The competition was tough too — each composer wanted to work for the finest patron, crown or church. The most important names, Bach, Handel, Mozart, Haydn, Beethoven, and so on, all performed like that.

As Western classical music grew out of Christianity, it was intended to accompany religious services, and coming up with new dedicated material was the daily expectation of the appointed composers. The repetition of the old was not advised either. Music was dedicated to God and a testament of dedication and discipline.

Hans Zimmer

Hans Zimmer

But then music, over the centuries and just like many things, became an industry… and entered the world of Hollywood. So much so that today some of the most successful composers are in fact film composers, such as Zimmer. The irony of it all is that now film music has entered the concert hall, and rather than taking up space in cinemas, it takes life in music venues. It is quite common to see listings of soundtracks being performed in their entirety, to the projected film, or not. What a three-hundred and sixty surprising twist; music for images, without the images.

Bach was not brought to the forefront before Mendelssohn exposed him again to the world, and most composers after their death would fall into oblivion. It was all about the new, until somehow, it shifted towards the old. Somehow, a fascination for the past, rather than the present, developed. But the promotion of old music in disfavour of new music is not a consequence of a lack of quality from existing composers. In fact, there are a plethora of immensely talented composers all over the world. Inventive, creative and curious musicians who perhaps deserve a better place in concert halls…

Friday, February 20, 2026

6 of the Most Romantic Symphonies in Classical Music History

  

For one, a symphony can be stylistically of the Romantic Era – Romantic-with-a-capital-R, full of sweeping melodies, warm orchestral colour, and heart-tugging harmonies.

But a symphony can also be romantic in a more personal sense: when it springs from a composer’s love for someone – or even somewhere.

Today, we’re looking at six symphonies that are Romantic in both senses of the word: stylistically of the era, and emotionally rooted in a love story.

All six of these works remain among the most popular romantic symphonies in the classical repertoire.

Romantic classical symphonies

Berlioz – Symphonie fantastique (1830)

The Love Story

This symphony’s autobiographical program was directly inspired by Berlioz’s own tumultuous love life and romantic fixations.

In 1827, after seeing Irish actress Harriet Smithson perform the role of Ophelia in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Berlioz became obsessively infatuated with her.

Although the production was in English, Smithson’s performance was so gripping that it electrified Parisian audiences.

Hector Berlioz in 1832

Hector Berlioz in 1832

One audience member in particular was electrified: Hector Berlioz.

He fell in love not with Smithson as a person – he wouldn’t get to know her for quite some time – but rather with her talent and appearance, as well as the many Romantic Era ideals she represented.

While in the throes of this fixation, Berlioz channeled his infatuation into a symphony.   

The music is programmatic and, in Berlioz’s own words, follows a “young artist of morbidly sensitive temperament” (a not-so-subtle stand-in for himself) as he plunges from ardent passion into the depths of delusion.

The beloved’s tender theme (idée fixe) is first heard in the symphony’s opening movement, but it later curdles into a vulgar fiddle tune in the witches’ sabbath, symbolising how his idealised love has turned into a nightmare.

The orchestration here is noteworthy, featuring an expanded percussion section, new instruments like the English horn, and striking effects like col legno bowing, where string players tap the wood of their bows on the strings to create spooky sounds.

Harriet Smithson

Harriet Smithson

Berlioz kept trying to get Smithson’s attention. He sent her numerous letters and even went so far as to stalk her lodgings, to no avail. In fact, she didn’t even attend the symphony’s 1830 premiere.

However, two years later, she finally heard a performance. She was astonished that she had inspired such a work, and they soon began dating.

They married in 1833. The marriage collapsed within a matter of years. But this symphony, the spark of inspiration that signaled the start of their relationship, remains a revolutionary Romantic Era statement that out-survived their love – and them.

Mendelssohn – Symphony No. 4, “Italian” (1833)

The Love Story

Horace Vernet: Felix Mendelssohn, 1831

Horace Vernet: Felix Mendelssohn, 1831

Felix Mendelssohn was not undergoing a tortured love affair while writing the Italian Symphony.

In fact, this work is more influenced by a place he loved than a person: the “romance” here is between the composer and Italy itself.

Mendelssohn’s letters from his 1830–31 Italian journey are ecstatic in their admiration.

“This is Italy! … the supreme joy in life. And I am loving it,” he wrote to his family.   

Each movement of the symphony takes on a different aspect of the life he observed in Italy. The joyful first movement is followed by a slow movement reflecting a religious procession he saw in Naples. The dance of the third movement is a standard minuet and trio, and the final movement incorporates two different Italian dances, the quick Roman saltarello (a jumping dance), and the Neapolitan tarantella.

Its joy makes it one of the most “Romantic” – if not overtly romantic – symphonies of the era. Read more about Mendelssohn’s Symphony No. 4.

Schumann – Symphony No. 1 “Spring” (1841)

The Love Story

Robert and Clara Schumann

Robert and Clara Schumann

The “Spring” Symphony emerged from the happiest period of Robert Schumann’s life: his first year of marriage to pianist Clara Wieck.

After years of struggling to win the approval of Clara’s father, the star-crossed lovers were finally able to marry in September 1840.

This personal triumph sparked an extraordinary burst of creativity. 1840 had been Robert’s “Year of Song,” when he poured his love into over a hundred love songs.

But by 1841, with Clara’s encouragement, he had turned to the symphony.

She wrote in her diary:

“It would be best if he composed for orchestra; his imagination cannot find sufficient scope on the piano… His compositions are all orchestral in feeling… My highest wish is that he should compose for orchestra – that is his field! May I succeed in bringing him to it!”

As for his part, Robert later said that the work was inspired not just by spring’s external imagery but by his own “spring of love” (“Liebesfrühling”).   

Astonishingly, Schumann sketched this symphony out over just four days in January 1841. It exudes all of the exuberance you might expect from such an energetic start.

Schumann wanted the opening trumpet fanfare “to sound as if it came from on high, like a summons to awakening,” heralding spring’s (and love’s) arrival. This motto theme, bold and hopeful, recurs as a unifying idea.

He crafted music that somehow sounds like spring, featuring buoyant rhythms, anticipatory tremolo passages in the strings, and woodwind passages that resemble birdsong.

Throughout, the symphony’s tone is one of youthful hope, excitement, and, importantly, satisfaction. It’s very much in line with Romantic Era ideas and idealism about the rejuvenating power of both love and nature.

Tchaikovsky – Symphony No. 4 (1877)

The Love Story

Tchaikovsky with his wife Antonina Milykova

Tchaikovsky with his wife Antonina Milykova

Few symphonies are as closely tied to a composer’s personal emotional life as Tchaikovsky’s Fourth.

Written in 1877, it coincided with a period of acute turmoil in Tchaikovsky’s romantic and emotional life.

That year, against his better judgment, Tchaikovsky entered into a hasty marriage with a young conservatory student, Antonina Miliukova – a marriage that proved disastrous and lasted only weeks before he fled her forever.

Tchaikovsky may have hoped marriage might quell rumours about his homosexuality, but the reality drove him to a nervous breakdown.   

During the aftermath of this catastrophic marriage, Tchaikovsky poured his inner despair and conflict into his fourth symphony.

He described the opening fanfare as the “Fate” that hangs over a person’s life: a concept that colored the entire symphony.

In a candid letter to his patroness and confidante, Nadezhda von Meck, Tchaikovsky admitted: “I was very depressed last winter when writing the symphony, and it is a faithful echo of what I was experiencing.”

Madame von Meck, who became Tchaikovsky’s benefactor in 1877, actually played a critical role in the symphony’s creation and the composer’s life at that particular time.

She provided financial support so he could quit teaching, along with an emotionally intimate – if strictly epistolary – friendship.

Nadezhda von Meck

Nadezhda von Meck

The dedication of the fourth symphony even reads “To my best friend”: Tchaikovsky’s tribute to von Meck, and a thank-you for helping to usher him through an especially trying time in his life.

It’s ironic that one of the most infamous marital breakdowns in classical music history inspired one of the standout symphonies of the Romantic Era.

Mahler – Symphony No. 5 (1901–02)

The Love Story

Alma Schindler in 1902

Alma Schindler, 1902

The years 1901–1902, when Mahler composed his Fifth Symphony, were momentous in his personal life, especially in terms of romantic love.

In November 1901, Gustav Mahler met Alma Schindler, a young composer and socialite from Vienna.

Their whirlwind courtship was intense; by March 1902, they were married. (Alma was pregnant at their wedding.)

This intense new love had a profound impact on Mahler, and we see its reflection most clearly in the symphony’s Adagietto.   

According to Alma’s testimony, the Fifth’s Adagietto (which starts at the 46:15 mark in the video above) was Mahler’s love song to her.

Historians have noted that Alma’s picturesque storytelling isn’t always strictly accurate, but the following story remains persuasive. Apparently, he left her a small poem with the Adagietto’s manuscript, saying: “How much I love you, my sun, I cannot tell you in words – only my longing and my love and my bliss.”

Today, the Adagietto is regarded as the wordless love letter from Mahler to his new wife, communicating in music what he felt he was unable to say in words.

It provides a transcendent counterbalance to the earthiness of the rest of the symphony, enhanced by its orchestration for strings and harp alone.

Rachmaninoff – Symphony No. 2 (1907)

The Love Story

Sergei Rachmaninoff and Natalia Satina

Sergei Rachmaninoff and Natalia Satina

The creation of his Symphony No. 2 marked a particularly redemptive chapter in Rachmaninoff’s professional life: one shaped by the support and love he found in his marriage.

A decade earlier, in 1897, Rachmaninoff’s first symphony had premiered to disastrous reviews (one critic likened it to “a program symphony about the Ten Plagues of Egypt”).

The fiasco of that premiere sent the young composer into a deep depression and a creative block. He recovered only with the help of therapy and through composing his successful Second Piano Concerto (1901).

During that same period, he fell in love with and became engaged to Natalia Satina, his cousin and childhood sweetheart.

After overcoming significant obstacles (including family disapproval and Orthodox Church restrictions on cousin marriage), Sergei and Natalia married in 1902 on a rainy spring day.

By the time he was writing the second symphony in 1906, Rachmaninoff had been happily married for a few years and was a father. His first daughter, Irina, was born in 1903, and his second, Tatiana, was born in 1907.

Enjoying such a stable, loving home life provided Rachmaninoff with a foundation of emotional security that was crucial to his productivity after the turmoil of his earlier years.  

In late 1906, he and Natalia moved to Dresden specifically to escape the pressures of Moscow so that he could focus on composition in peace.

There, with his wife and daughter by his side, he worked on the symphony – though not without bouts of self-doubt.

At one point, he nearly abandoned the score, calling it “boring and repulsive” in a typical burst of self-criticism, before eventually returning to it.

It’s easy to imagine that the heartfelt outpouring of the symphony – especially its incandescent Adagio – was nurtured by the contentment and warmth of Rachmaninoff’s married life.

The triumphant premiere of the symphony in early 1908 in St. Petersburg was a vindication; the public and critics hailed it, and it earned Rachmaninoff a prestigious Glinka Award.

Today it remains one of the symphonic highlights of the late Romantic Era, beloved for its lush string writing and deeply felt, warmly expressed emotion.

Conclusion

Romanticism in symphonic music wasn’t just an artistic movement; it was also a way for composers to transform their private longing, devotion, and emotional crisis into publicly performed art.

From Berlioz’s hallucinatory passion in the Symphonie fantastique to Rachmaninoff’s newfound confidence in his Second, these six works reveal how love – fulfilled, frustrated, or otherwise – shaped some of the most powerful music of the Romantic Era.

Taken together, they show just how deeply composers’ love stories shaped their compositions, and why these pieces remain so easy to love even today.

Friday, January 9, 2026

Mendelssohn: The Hebrides Overture Premiered Today in 1833

  

Exterior of Fingal’s Cave

Exterior of Fingal’s Cave

Described as one of the natural wonders of Scotland, Fingal’s Cave is located on the uninhabited island of Staffa, in the Inner Hebrides. Formed from hexagonally jointed basalt columns it became known as “Fingal’s Cave” after the hero of an epic poem by the Scottish historian James Macpherson. It was part of his highly influential Ossian cycle of poems supposedly based on old Scottish Gaelic verse.

Fingal’s Cave

Fingal’s Cave

And when the novelist Sir Walter Scott visited the cave, he wrote, “it is one of the most extraordinary places I ever held. It exceeded in my mind, every description I had heard of it…. as high as the roof of a cathedral, and running deep into the rock, eternally swept by a deep and swelling sea”. Other famous visitors to the cave included the author Jules Verne, poets Wordsworth, Keats and Tennyson, the painter J.M.W. Turner and Queen Victoria. And then there was Felix Mendelssohn, who visited the cave in 1829 during his tour of Scotland.


Mendelssohn's sketch of Scottish Landscape

Mendelssohn’s sketch of Scottish Landscape

In July and August 1829, Mendelssohn and his poet friend Karl Klingemann visited Edinburgh and Abbotsford. He began to draft the opening of his Symphony No. 3—eventually to be subtitled “Scottish”—and he wrote to his sister Fanny. “In order to have you understand how extraordinarily the Hebrides affect me, the following came to my mind.” And that postcard contained the opening phrase of what would eventually become his Hebrides Overture. It is been suggested that the echoes Mendelssohn experienced in the cave inspired this particular theme, although there is no definitive proof that Mendelssohn ever got close enough. The first complete draft of the work was completed on 16 December 1830 and entitled “The Lonely Island.” Not entirely satisfied with the work, Mendelssohn embarked on a series of revisions. The final version, now titled “Hebrides Overture,” was completed on 20 June 1832, and it premiered on 10 January 1833 in Berlin with the composer conducting. Richard Wagner subsequently called the work “one of the most beautiful pieces we possess.”